NWCDN Members regularly post articles and summary judgements in workers’ compensations law in your state.
Select a state from the dropdown menu below to scroll through the state specific archives for updates and opinions on various workers’ compensation laws in your state.
Contact information for NWCDN members is also located on the state specific links in the event you have additional questions or your company is seeking a workers’ compensation lawyer in your state.
No, not that Meta.
Meta-analysis of medical data. We were surprised to read an article
summarizing that many common orthopedic procedures don’t have a lot of evidence
supporting their efficacy. The article reviewed the 8 most common
surgical procedures and compared the outcome to non-surgical treatment of the
underlying conditions. In only two cases did the study show that surgical
treatment was the more effective – carpal tunnel release, and total knee
replacement. The study showed no difference in outcome for partial
meniscectomy, rotatory cuff repair, subacromial decompression, anterior
cruciate ligament reconstruction, lumbar spine decompression, and lumbar
fusion. One wonders if before recommending these surgeries to injured
workers their doctors make this information available to them. We wish someone
would do a study specific to Texas workers’ compensation medical treatment, and
better yet, to individual surgeons who are frequent actors in the Texas system.
A link to the article is here.
Copyright 2022, Stone Loughlin & Swanson, LLP
As of this month, the DWC has yet another revised Employer’s Wage Statement on its website. We appreciate that there is no “fine print” and the form is much easier to read and to understand and the instructions attached to are much clearer than those that came with the prior form. This is a good time to remind our readers that it is the employer’s responsibility to complete this form and file it with the insurance carrier, the claimant, and the claimant’s representative within the earliest of the date the employer is notified that the employee is entitled to income benefits, or the the date the employee’s death is a result of a compensable injury; and within seven days of getting a request from DWC for a copy of the form. The employer can be fined for failure to provide a DWC 3, but the consequence to the carrier of the employer’s failure to comply is sometimes only realized when the carrier makes a claim to the Subsequent Injury Fund for reimbursement. If DWC can’t verify the correct Average Weekly Wage by reviewing an accurately completed DWC 3, reimbursement is likely to be denied. You can find the new form here.
Copyright 2022, Stone Loughlin & Swanson, LLP
We have learned that,
effective September 1, 2022, ombudsmen are now required to place a call to a
Claimant who fails to timely call or Zoom into a benefit review conference.
While we have yet to see a formal memo or bulletin confirming this new policy,
we think it a good one which may avoid needless delay in the dispute resolution
process resulting from an unrepresented Claimant’s forgetfulness or inability
to negotiate the Zoom platform. Rather than simply resetting the proceeding to
a later date, we think a call from the ombudsman to the non-appearing Claimant
may salvage the BRC setting and result in productive mediation of the parties’
disputes.
Copyright 2022, Stone Loughlin & Swanson, LLP
The Division has announced the State AWW and maximum/minimum weekly benefits
for the period from October 1, 2022 through September 30, 2023 as follows:
State Average Weekly Wage:
$1,111.55
Maximum Temporary Income Benefits: $1,112.00
Minimum Temporary Income Benefits: $
167.00
Maximum Impairment Income Benefits: $ 778.00
Minimum Impairment Income Benefits: $
167.00
Maximum Supplemental Income Benefits: $ 778.00
Maximum Lifetime Income Benefits:
$1,112.00
Minimum Lifetime Income Benefits:
$ 167.00
Maximum Death Benefits:
$1,112.00
Copyright 2022, Stone Loughlin & Swanson, LLP
The Division is accepting public comments on amendments to Rule 102.11(b)(1).
The proposed rule was published in the September 23, 2022 issue of the Texas Register and on the TDI
website. Comments may be submitted through 5:00 p.m. on October 24, 2022.
Insofar as the amended rule simply corrects and updates the address of the
Division website providing specific data requirements, data set transactions,
data mapping, data edits and fees per record to the correct current domain, we
expect few comments will be received.
The proposed changes direct the public to www.tdi.texas.gov/wc.
A copy of the proposed rule may be accessed here:
http://www.tdi.texas.gov/wc/rules/2022rules.html
Copyright 2022, Stone Loughlin & Swanson, LLP
We reported back in April, 2021 that the Division would be relocating its
Austin headquarters to the new Capitol Complex at 1601 Congress Avenue in the
summer of 2022.
In May of this year, however, we reported that plans had changed and
operations, including hearings, would continue at the current Metro Center
Drive location through the summer of 2022. The move date to the new location
would be announced when finalized.
Although we have seen no formal announcement, we now understand that the Austin
Field Office will move to the new Barbara Jordan State Office Building at 1601
Congress Avenue on October 10. Director of Media Relations for the Division,
Kate Sidora, advises that there are still a few items to work out but nothing
that will change the move-in date. We are not yet certain where system
participants with business in the field office will be required to park but
will update readers in the near future.
Copyright 2022, Stone Loughlin & Swanson, LLP
Readers may recall our
report in the March, 2022 installment of The Compendium
that Dr. Clinton Battle of Arlington Occupational and Medical Clinic had been
sentenced to 12 years in federal prison following his conviction for conspiracy
to distribute controlled substances and distribution of controlled substances.
Dr. Battle also pled guilty to conspiracy to commit mail fraud.
The U.S. Department of Justice advised in September, however, that Dr. Battle’s
scheduled release date has been changed to September 26, 2030. He is not
eligible for parole and will be 77 years old when released from prison.
Dr. Battle is also required to pay $376,368.00 in restitution and will be under
supervised release for three years after his imprisonment.
Copyright 2022, Stone Loughlin & Swanson, LLP
Chiropractors play a vital role in the Texas workers’ compensation system.
Therefore, we like to keep our readers apprised of the latest developments in
the field of chiropractic.
We don’t know much about TikTok; however, we understand this social media platform,
which enables subscribers to create and share short videos, is “blowing-up”
over a controversial new trend: chiropractic treatments for babies….babies as
young as 6 days old.
Proponents claim that the gentle “baby adjustments” are effective treatment for
a variety of baby ailments including colic, constipation, reflux,
musculoskeletal issues, and even the trauma experienced in childbirth.
Although manual treatments to address spinal conditions in adults were
reportedly used by Hippocrates around 400 B.C. and by Buddhist monks dating
back over 2,000 years, chiropractic as a “modern” profession began in 1895 when
Daniel David Palmer adjusted the spine of a deaf janitor which, Palmer claimed,
restored the janitor’s hearing. The primary issue, we understand, is
subluxation. Subluxations, or misalignments of the spinal vertebrae, are
thought by chiropractors to compromise and influence the function and health of
the nervous system in general and the various organ systems in the body.
Proponents argue that adjustments by a trained, qualified, and knowledgeable
practitioner to correct subluxation therefore promote proper nervous and organ
system function and health in general.
But for babies?
As you might expect, many physicians have expressed concern that spinal
manipulation of babies places them at greater risk for injury to their soft
developing bones and over-stretching of their looser joints. According to an
article in the Washington Post, one orthopedic surgeon at Children’s National
Hospital in Washington D.C., Dr. Sean Tabaie, commented that there is no way
one would achieve improvement in a newborn from manipulation. “The only thing
you might possibly cause is harm.”
On the other hand, a recent study of 58 colicky babies in Spain found that light
touch therapy resulted in a significant reduction of crying in those babies
receiving the treatment. The parents of the babies were aware of the treatment,
however, which can cause biased reporting of results.
And following a 2021 study in Denmark of 185 colicky babies, researchers
indicated data suggested that babies receiving chiropractic treatment “seemed”
to cry less; however, the findings were deemed not to be statistically
significant.
Call us old-fashioned, but we think we would opt for the extended 3:00 a.m. car
ride to soothe a colicky baby.
Copyright 2022, Stone Loughlin & Swanson, LLP
As we remind readers
on a regular basis, Stone, Loughlin & Swanson is a Founding Sponsor and
long-time supporter of Kids’ Chance of Texas, an organization whose mission is
to create and support scholarship programs to provide educational opportunities
for children in Texas who have had a parent catastrophically or fatally injured
while in the course and scope of his or her employment. As participants in the
Texas Workers’ Compensation system, we are particularly aware of the
devastating toll such an injury takes on a family and, especially, the
children.
Please help us continue to help the kids by becoming a participant or sponsor
and joining us for fun and camaraderie at The Cowboys Golf Club on October 28
for the Third Annual Kids’ Chance Texas Golf Tournament.
All proceeds will fund Kids’ Chance of Texas scholarships which has awarded
over $75,000 for the fall semester alone. Come help us reach our goal of
raising $150,000 while enjoying the delightfully maddening frustration that
only golfers can appreciate.
There is still time to help the kids this month! For more information and to
register as a player and/or sponsor, click here:
https://www.kidschanceoftexas.org/events/golf2022/
Copyright 2022, Stone Loughlin & Swanson, LLP
We are saddened to
announce that Gary Lynn Kilgore, long time Administrative Law Judge and Appeals
Panel Judge, with the Texas Workers’ Compensation Commission and the Texas
Department of Insurance-Division of Workers’ Compensation, passed away on September
23, 2022 at the age of 69.
Mr. Kilgore attended college at the University of Virginia and earned his Juris
Doctor in 1978 at the University of Texas School of Law. He served as managing
partner of Garcia & Kilgore, attorneys, for over 16 years before joining
the Texas Workers’ Compensation Commission where he served as an Appeals Panel
Judge for 12 years.
Thereafter, Gary heard cases as a Hearing Officer with the Division of Workers’
Compensation for 4 years before serving as Associate Director of Legal Services
with the Office of Injured Employee Counsel, in which capacity he served for
over 13 years.
Mr. Kilgore returned to the Appeals Panel in 2019 prior to his retirement this
year.
Those of us that knew Gary found him to be a wealth of knowledge regarding the
workers’ compensation law and institutional system in Texas. He was an
outstandingly gifted writer, a delightful conversationalist, and a student of
the law and American and world history. We will miss you, Gary….
Copyright 2022, Stone Loughlin & Swanson, LLP